Based on extensive experience in M&A for mid-sized B2B industrial companies, the following are the most common sticking points during Term Sheet negotiations:
- Valuation Discrepancies
- Issue: Differences between the buyer's and seller's perceived value of the company.
- Resolution: Detailed financial models and third-party valuations can help bridge gaps. Structuring deals with earn-out provisions can also align future performance with valuation.
- Earn-Out Provisions
- Issue: Conditions for additional payments based on future performance often lead to disagreements.
- Resolution: Clear, measurable KPIs and timelines must be established. Including caps on potential earn-outs can provide certainty for both parties.
- Representations and Warranties
- Issue: Sellers need to assure buyers about the company's condition and operations. Differences in what should be guaranteed can be contentious.
- Resolution: Detailed disclosure schedules and indemnity caps help mitigate risk. Buyers may require insurance for additional protection.
- Indemnification Clauses
- Issue: Provisions for covering potential future liabilities can be heavily negotiated.
- Resolution: Establishing caps on indemnity and time limitations for claims can provide balance. Sellers might insist on escrow accounts to cover potential claims.
- Non-Compete Agreements
- Issue: Restrictions on the seller's future business activities can be problematic, especially if the seller is active in the industry.
- Resolution: Defining reasonable timeframes and geographic scopes for non-competes is crucial. Compensation for agreeing to non-competes can also be negotiated.
- Employment Agreements
- Issue: Terms for retaining key employees post-acquisition are often critical.
- Resolution: Offering attractive retention packages, including bonuses and equity participation, can help secure key talent. Clearly defining roles and responsibilities post-acquisition is also essential.
Examples and Data Points
- Valuation Discrepancy Example
- Scenario: In a recent acquisition of a mid-sized manufacturing company, the primary sticking point was the valuation discrepancy. The seller valued the company at $50 million, while the buyer's offer was $40 million.
- Resolution: The deal was structured with a $45 million upfront payment and an additional $5 million earn-out contingent on achieving specific revenue targets over the next two years.
- Earn-Out Provision Example
- Scenario: A technology company acquisition involved significant differences in earn-out expectations. The seller wanted aggressive growth targets for additional payments, while the buyer preferred conservative benchmarks.
- Resolution: They agreed on a tiered earn-out structure with varying payments for different levels of performance, with a maximum cap of $10 million.
- Representations and Warranties Example
- Scenario: During the acquisition of an industrial equipment supplier, extensive negotiations were needed on representations regarding environmental compliance.
- Resolution: Detailed environmental audits were conducted, and specific indemnities were included for any pre-existing issues, with a cap of $2 million.
- Indemnification Clause Example
- Scenario: In the sale of a chemicals company, indemnification for potential future litigation was a major concern.
- Resolution: An indemnity escrow account was established, holding 10% of the purchase price for two years, providing both parties with assurance.
- Non-Compete Agreement Example
- Scenario: The sale of a construction services firm required the seller to agree not to compete for five years, but the seller felt this was too long.
- Resolution: They compromised on a three-year non-compete agreement with a $1 million compensation for adherence.
- Employment Agreement Example
- Scenario: In an acquisition of an engineering consulting firm, retaining key engineers was critical.
- Resolution: Key employees were offered three-year contracts with performance bonuses and equity options to ensure their commitment.
Clarifying Questions
To further tailor the advice and provide more specific insights, contact me with:
- The particular industry of the target company?
- Any specific concerns or goals the owners have expressed regarding the sale?
- The size of the company in terms of revenue, employees, or market share?